I-9 Audit Checklist: Everything You Need to Know

9 minutes read

It is important for employers to complete their I-9 forms properly for each employee they hire under the Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) of 1986. Employers can face criminal punishment if the I-9 forms defy verification and employment eligibility requirements.

To prevent any mistakes in your I-9 forms, it is helpful to regularly conduct an I-9 audit internally. Below is our I-9 audit checklist to help you conduct the audit seamlessly and ensure that you don’t forget anything during the process.

What You’ll Need

In order to perform your I-19 audit correctly and thoroughly, you’ll need the following:

  • List of current employees
  • List of employees that were terminated in the past three years
  • Copies of all I-9 forms (either original or electronic)
  • Current I-9 form requirements
  • Up-to-date version of the USCIS’s Form I-9 M-247 Handbook for Employers

I-9 Audit Checklist Steps

1. Employee Information

First, ensure that you have the following information available for each employee and check to see if it is correct:

  • Employee first and last names
  • N/A for “Other Names Used” if it is not applicable
  • Maiden name or other names if it applies
  • Full address (excluding PO boxes)
  • Date of birth in mm/dd/yyyy format.
  • Social Security number (this is mandatory for E-Verify participants)

2. Citizenship or Immigration Status

Check to see that the following information regarding citizenship or immigration status is correct and competed:

  • Status (Make sure only one is selected)
    • Lawful Permanent Resident: make sure the alien registration number is included
    • An Alien Authorized to Work: ensure the work until date, alien number or admission number is correct
  • Expiration date of employment authorization

3. Employee’s Attestation

Next, you’ll want to review your employee’s attestation. Ensure these next items are complete and accurate:

  • Employee’s signature
  • Date of employee’s execution of form
  • Date of employees first day

* I-9 must be signed within 3 days of start3

4. Identity and Employment Eligibility Provided Documents (List A)

Ensure you have the appropriate information regarding identity and employment eligibility as well:

  • Correct document listed
  • List A document title
  • List A document issuing authority
  • List A document number
  • List A document expiration date
  • Receipt showing accepted application for document

5. Identity (List B)

For List B, ensure the following are complete and accurate:

  • List B document title
  • List B document issuing authority
  • List B document number
  • List B document expiration date if applicable
  • Receipt showing accepted application for document

6. Employment Authorization (List C)

For List C, ensure the following are complete and accurate:

  • List C document title
  • List C document issuing authority
  • List C document number
  • List C document expiration date if applicable
  • Receipt showing accepted application for document

7. Employer’s Certification Information

Next, review your employer’s certification information by checking the following for accuracy and completion:

  • Employee’s first day of employment in mm/dd/yyyy format
  • Signature of Employer/Authorized Representative in the correct box
  • Date of certification in mm/dd/yyyy format
  • Certification signed within three days of hire
  • Title of Authorized Representative
  • Last Name and First Name of Authorized Representative
  • Employer’s Business or Organization Name
  • Address of business (No P.O. boxes are allowed)

8. Reverification Requirements

The only instance reverification is applicable is if employment authorization evidence presented in Section 2 becomes expired. You do not need to reverify US citizens, noncitizen nationals, or Lawful Permanent Residents.

However, if reverification is necessary, check for completion and accuracy of the following items:

  • Date of rehire in mm/dd/yyyy format if applicable
  • New name listed if applicable
  • Document title
  • Document number
  • Employment authorization document
  • Expiration Date in mm/dd/yyyy format
  • Signature of Authorized Representative present
  • Date of company certification in mm/dd/yyyy format
  • Printed name of Authorized Representative

What To Do About Missing I-9’s

Protocol for missing I-9’s differs between current and former employees. For current employees, have your employee present the appropriate documentation and complete an I-9, filling it out with the current dates. Then, attach a note explaining why there is a discrepancy between the hiring date and the I-9 form completion date.

For former employees, date and attach a note to an I-9 form for former employees, filling out any missing or incorrect information. Then, put the form with your other I-9 forms.

What To Do with I-9s with Errors

If the errors are easily correctable, you can correct these errors directly on the form. Cross out the incorrect information in a contrasting color of ink and put the correct information next to it. Initial and date next to each correction. If the errors cannot be corrected easily, you must complete a new I-9 form. Attach this new form to the new one with a note that explains why you are filling out a new form. Make sure to not throw away the old form.

How to Store I-9’s

Keep your I-9 forms separate from employee personnel files. It is strongly recommended to store your I-9 forms both electronically and in the form of a hard copy. Ensure that these files are only able to be accessed by a few HR representatives.

EPAY Can Help Improve Your HR Department’s Efficiency

From our human management software to our helpful human resources-related tips, EPAY is here to help your human resources department run more smoothly. For more information on proper I-9 practices or if you have other HR-related questions, please contact our team at EPAY today.

Popular Articles

10 Best Practices: Mobile Time and Attendance Tracking
Constructing Your Overtime Policy (and Free Sample Overtime Policy)
Smart Attendance Policies for the Hourly Workforce
What is the Difference Between Time Theft vs. Wage Theft
9 Performance Management Best Practices for Hourly Workers

Posts by Tag

workplace culture
Workforce Management
Wage Garnishment
Time Tracking

Request a Demo

See how EPAY’s human capital management system brings all of your HR technology together in one easy-to-use platform.